On by Adam Roberts

Imagine the whole world is a cliff, a wall stretching out above and below you farther than the eye can see. The sky arcs not above, not a dome above your head, but rather from the hazy depths below, to the hazy depths above, the otherness that hangs alongside the wall as you do.  You are a young man who lives — who has always lived — on a small ledge of the cliff, among a small cluster of ledges where your village is situated. There are no trees, no roaring ocean waves nearby — you have no word for …

Continue Reading

Meme: women in SF

The Rules of the Game (as teefed from Aliette de Bodard’s blog) Are: Bold the women by whom you own books Italicize those by whom you’ve read something of (short stories count). *Star those you don’t recognize Unmarked are those whose work you have not read (And I’ve got some comments on the original list at the end, which may be of more interest than the list itself…)

Continue Reading

Man of Steel, Woman of Kleenex (video), and Grading Adventures

Interesting thing: I am typing up the response sheets to the final essays for students in my Understanding English & American Pop Cultures course, and I actually had occasion to pass along the link to this video to one student who discussed Superman: (It is, of course, based very closely on Larry Niven’s original story.) I am not going to say more about superheroes, because I feel as if I’m a bit superhero-ed out, to be honest. It’s a huge genre, and there’s so much I don’t know about it… but I imagine it’d be fun to teach a whole …

Continue Reading

Five more on Kick-Ass, Part 5

This entry is part 5 of 5 in the series Five More on Kick-Ass: A Response to Criticisms of the Film

[UPDATE: For the first twelve hours this post was online, somehow an earlier draft went live, instead of the final version. I’ve just restored the autosaved final draft. So this post looks different than it did ten minutes (or ten hours) ago.] ORIGINAL POST: This is the final post in a series that began with Part 1. I recommend beginning there, and following the links at the end of each section to work through the following posts in the series (of which there will be five). Here we are, at the end of an evisceration. Feels like the end of the …

Continue Reading

Five more on Kick-Ass, Part 4

This entry is part 4 of 5 in the series Five More on Kick-Ass: A Response to Criticisms of the Film

This is the penultimate post in a series that began with Part 1. I recommend beginning there, and following the links at the end of each section to work through the following posts in the series (of which there will be five). Here’s the next segment of the criticism to which I’m responding: “Kick-Ass” is rated R, which means that adults are free to take children to watch a child hurting adults: a neatly wrapped package, like “Home Alone” on growth hormones. I’m going to rephrase this, critically, as the following argument: Whatever one thinks of violence in film, children harming adults is, …

Continue Reading

Five more on Kick-Ass, Part 3

This entry is part 3 of 5 in the series Five More on Kick-Ass: A Response to Criticisms of the Film

This is the third post in a series that began with Part 1. I recommend beginning there, and following the links at the end of each section to work through the following posts in the series (of which there will be five). The third claim embedded in the criticism of Kick-Ass to which I’m responding is found here in the original passage: Goldman would presumably say that it is violence, not sex, that our pre-teen heroine learns, but that is a cowardly distinction—although, to be fair, it is a cowardice shared by everyone from the M.P.A.A. down…. when filmmakers nudge a child into …

Continue Reading

Five More on Kick-Ass, Part 2

This entry is part 2 of 5 in the series Five More on Kick-Ass: A Response to Criticisms of the Film

This is the second post in a series that began with Part 1. I recommend beginning there, and following the links at the end of each section to work through the following posts in the series (of which there will be five). In my last post, I showed how the claim that Kick-Ass, in its presentation of Mindy/Hit-Girl in a schoolgirl uniform, doesn’t constitute sexualization of children as much as the critic’s claim therein constituted the revelation of a desire to desexualize, infantilize, and otherwise impose degrading and confusing controls both on the depiction of children in media, but also (and more distressingly) …

Continue Reading

A New Kind of Fiction?

Probably not, just as Stephen Wolfram’s book A New Kind of Science doesn’t really seem to have launched a new kind of science into being.  (From the condition of the copy I have on hand, I’m apparently the only person ever to have signed it out of my university’s library — though perhaps that’s because it’s available online for free?) In any case, I don’t know how well-explored this field is, but it seems to me the logical extension of the online treatment of SF — moving from short stories to flash fiction and then to twitterfiction — might lead …

Continue Reading

Five More on Kick-Ass, Part 1.

This entry is part 1 of 5 in the series Five More on Kick-Ass: A Response to Criticisms of the Film

A response to my post on Kick-Ass showed up on the LJ mirror of this blog, and I decided I wanted to respond to it here, where it could be more widely seen. The comment went like this: You’re the third person I’ve heard or seen recommend this movie (hadn’t looked at any reviews). The others were [my friend] and Peter Watts. What I want to know is your response to criticism like this: “Kick-Ass” is violence’s answer to kiddie porn. You can see it in Hit Girl’s outfit when she cons her way past security guards—white blouse, hair in …

Continue Reading